{
 "instrument": "THE DESK · A PREREGISTERED INSTRUMENT",
 "address": "https://desk.thesecondbitcoin.com/",
 "as_of": "2026-07-25",
 "law": "39 ways to be proven wrong, frozen before a single reading. Missing data is not a zero. Green renders only on a verified reading.",
 "frozen_hashes": {
  "survey_sha256": "df4abafad31727f8908cfc8cb3fe28abbba416f270f7f97fb6a64d4bac42cd24",
  "plates_sha256": "87e030e392b0c631d8250304821f6054434bb65e2443fd04e14eea313927fee6",
  "alias_sha256": "f65e86f7c34cea5b592d2429bd64b7d44cfbdc85464d4d2ca5463d7fbf6ef414",
  "model_js_sha256": "59273fd255c79ab654cc37c92c8926079f06acd677deb4e678083a9d6397ffb2",
  "claims_raw_sha256": "7e655a43e4645b19bc935c60efa695f25460bce53faf65446c5c9ac63bfb96c9",
  "registry_canonical_sha256": "08e926f6c06e4876a6a2fc81a7e5ed566cf698e865679d688a288f9581db9b06",
  "labels_sha256": "6f93e007b8209b143394f7729459b974f0cefb73ce1f18c24221ac8443a5de25",
  "cultural_structure_sha256": "d509354b1fd714722526773e619cf520354edca4670cd7452c267084b917981b",
  "voice_manifest_sha256": "c4b4f56ca541ef2a2dc25a00c90ec6f36d505d76f2d7dd0fbe9a213eee498cad",
  "panels_sha256": "0a62f627700598050d169c4b4e9aecb6628a43693b62d0b115598c40d04f8eee"
 },
 "ratification": {
  "record": "P0 SURVEY & LAW — OPERATOR RATIFICATION",
  "date": "2026-07-25",
  "law": "These three files change only by regenerating with a registry change or an operator directive, and every change is a WHAT CHANGED event. Editing them by hand is forbidden."
 },
 "claims": [
  {
   "id": "BTC-LIM-001",
   "question": "Can one consumer-verifiable chain absorb unlimited settlement demand?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Preserving broadly consumer-verifiable Bitcoin base-layer operation imposes finite settlement capacity; materially increasing base-layer throughput increases storage, bandwidth, validation, or operational burden.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Bitcoin’s Limit",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 12, Bitcoin’s Security Assumption and The Limit"
  },
  {
   "id": "BTC-LIM-002",
   "question": "Is this a temporary spike or a forcing regime?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Bitcoin will experience periods that meet an ex-ante Fee Regime rule combining elevated median fees, persistent mempool pressure, and confirmation uncertainty over a sustained window.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Bitcoin’s Limit",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 12; Ch. 13, Fee Regimes: Forced-Choice Events"
  },
  {
   "id": "BTC-LIM-003",
   "question": "Which transaction bands are being priced away from sovereignty?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "During Fee Regimes, fee burden as a share of transferred value will cross registered affordability thresholds first for smaller and middle transaction bands, raising the minimum viable size for direct sovereign settlement.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Bitcoin’s Limit",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 12, scarcity on both sides and monetization band"
  },
  {
   "id": "BTC-LIM-004",
   "question": "Do layers eliminate the constraint or move its cost?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Non-custodial layered systems will not absorb all overflow reliably at consumer scale without introducing material liquidity, routing, online-availability, operational, permission, or counterparty costs.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Bitcoin’s Limit",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 12, Second Layers Help but Do Not Eliminate the Constraint"
  },
  {
   "id": "BTC-LIM-005",
   "question": "What do users do when sovereignty is rationed by price?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Bitcoin Fee Regimes will produce measurable and persistent changes in at least one forced-choice path—pay and stay, internalize, or reroute—rather than leaving post-event behavior unchanged.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Bitcoin’s Limit",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 11–13, Forced-Choice Menu"
  },
  {
   "id": "LTC-BAND-001",
   "question": "Is the routed activity economically meaningful?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Litecoin’s event-linked activity increase will include economically relevant transfer bands; transaction count will not rise solely because the median and nearby quantiles collapse into dust-like values.",
   "state": "HISTORICAL_CANDIDATE",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "The Second Bitcoin",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 13, median and quantile argument; Ch. 14"
  },
  {
   "id": "LTC-COORD-001",
   "question": "Is retained use deepening coordination?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Repeated Litecoin retention will be followed by deeper integration coverage, usable liquidity, tighter or more resilient spreads, greater reliability, default placement, or repeat acceptance.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "The Second Bitcoin",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 13, Coordination Is the Moat"
  },
  {
   "id": "LTC-CORR-001",
   "question": "Do off-chain observations corroborate the routing story?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Independent routing proxies—processor share, exchange withdrawals, wallet behavior, merchant evidence, or payment defaults—will strengthen during Fee Regimes and will not fully unwind when Litecoin’s filtered on-chain floor is retained.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "The Second Bitcoin",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 13–14, independent routing proxies"
  },
  {
   "id": "LTC-CTRL-001",
   "question": "Is this Litecoin-specific retention or ‘everything went up’?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Litecoin’s post-regime retention will exceed matched changes in BCH, DOGE, DASH, XMR, and the broad crypto cycle under the registered control design.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "The Second Bitcoin",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 13, Proof-of-Work Substitution Controls"
  },
  {
   "id": "LTC-FLY-001",
   "question": "Is coordination making the next reroute easier?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "If Litecoin coordination deepens, subsequent Bitcoin Fee Regimes will produce faster, larger, or more durable Litecoin routing responses than earlier comparable regimes.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "The Second Bitcoin",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 13, coordination flywheel"
  },
  {
   "id": "LTC-RET-001",
   "question": "Does trial become retained habit?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "After multiple Bitcoin Fee Regimes, Litecoin’s economically filtered 30-, 90-, or 180-day activity floor will remain above its preregime baseline by a preregistered retention threshold.",
   "state": "HISTORICAL_CANDIDATE",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "The Second Bitcoin",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 13, trial → retention and post-regime baseline reset"
  },
  {
   "id": "LTC-SECOND-001",
   "question": "Has Litecoin crossed from substitute asset to coordinated second rail?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Litecoin qualifies as the coordinated second sovereign rail only if it uniquely combines repeated Fee-Regime substitution, economically meaningful post-event retention, external corroboration, and durable coordination advantages.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "The Second Bitcoin",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 13, Monetary Consolidation Principle and second-bitcoin claim"
  },
  {
   "id": "LTC-TRIAL-001",
   "question": "Does Litecoin receive event-linked trial activity?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "During preregistered Bitcoin Fee Regimes, economically filtered Litecoin activity will rise above its pre-event baseline by more than its normal variation.",
   "state": "HISTORICAL_CANDIDATE",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "The Second Bitcoin",
   "room": "ROOM-04-CASE-BTCLTC",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 13, narrow substitution claim"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-COHORT-001",
   "question": "Who has both the motive and capability to move first?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "High-skill, low-asset, digitally native, cross-border-capable participants will adopt exit tooling and non-custodial settlement earlier or more intensively than matched participants with greater incumbent-asset ownership.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Leaf",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 10 target market; Structure V1 §6.5, The Unbundled Generation"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-EXIT-001",
   "question": "How much productive autonomy is available today?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "For preregistered high-skill tasks, AI and local-model tools will reduce median time, monetary cost, and required institutional intermediation needed to produce and deliver equivalent-quality output.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 10, NDLM; Ch. 26, AI as Interface Layer"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-EXIT-002",
   "question": "Is productive economic life actually becoming more portable?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "The value and share of knowledge-intensive output produced and delivered digitally by individuals and small teams will rise over the registered window.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 10, Natively Digital Labor Market; Ch. 25"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-EXIT-003",
   "question": "Is sovereign settlement becoming operationally easier?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "The median time, cost, and failure rate required to acquire, self-custody, privately manage, and settle bearer value will decline faster than legal, tax, reporting, surveillance, and on-ramp frictions rise.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 11, Dial Two; Act III routing and interface"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-EXIT-004",
   "question": "Is exit becoming workflow rather than a technical possibility?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "The Exit Friction index may enter a low-friction state only when enabling-stack improvements are corroborated by repeat operational use; benchmark improvements alone cannot produce the state.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Composite",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 11, migration as workflow necessity; Structure V1 §6.4"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-MIG-001",
   "question": "Have the Two Dials crossed into migration?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Periods and populations in the high-Cost-of-Staying/low-Exit-Friction cell will show more persistent routing outside default rails than the other three Two Dials cells after controlling for market prices and general technology adoption.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 11, Two Dials 2×2 threshold matrix"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-STAY-001",
   "question": "What has accumulated relative to the system’s ability to carry it?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Across the jurisdictions represented by the index, consolidated public liabilities and projected debt service will rise faster than nominal productive output and recurring government revenue capacity over the registered measurement window.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 11, Dial One: Cost of Staying"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-STAY-002",
   "question": "Is the accumulated burden becoming a current bill?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "As existing obligations refinance under realized market rates, net interest outlays and interest-to-revenue ratios will rise, increasing current fiscal carrying cost.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 11, indefinite rollover and carrying-cost mechanism"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-STAY-003",
   "question": "How is the bill actually reaching people?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "A higher obligation and carrying-cost state will be followed by enacted and implemented transmission through at least one measurable channel: taxation, monetary dilution, negative real returns, financial repression, capital controls, spending cuts, or restructuring.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 11, pressure → conditionality → friction → rerouting"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-STAY-004",
   "question": "Is access becoming more conditional?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "During registered fiscal or monetary stress periods, the frequency or severity of settlement delays, reversals, withdrawal limits, reporting burdens, access restrictions, or freeze/seizure events will increase relative to matched normal periods.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Leaf",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 11, ‘your life becomes a queue’; diffusion from edge to center"
  },
  {
   "id": "MAC-STAY-005",
   "question": "Is staying measurably more expensive now?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "The Cost of Staying index may enter a high-cost state only when accumulated burden rises and at least one realized transmission family corroborates it; proposed policy or news coverage alone cannot produce the state.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Composite",
   "gate": "Macro Migration",
   "room": "ROOM-02-EXIT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 11, The Two Dials; Structure V1 §6.2–6.3"
  },
  {
   "id": "REG-LANG-001",
   "question": "Is public vocabulary beginning to catch up with behavior?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "After audited routing, retention, and settlement gates strengthen, independent search, media, and public-language adoption of the mechanism will rise with a measurable lag.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Regime Legibility",
   "room": "ROOM-06-RECOGNITION",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 16, Language/Sentiment and RLI"
  },
  {
   "id": "REG-LEG-001",
   "question": "Has the mechanism become mutually visible across behavior, language, and price?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Regime Legibility may enter its high state only when mechanism, behavior, language, and price panels independently meet their preregistered thresholds; no market overlay can repair a failed upstream gate.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Regime Legibility",
   "room": "ROOM-06-RECOGNITION",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 16, Regime Legibility Index; Structure V1 §11"
  },
  {
   "id": "REG-ORDER-001",
   "question": "Is the thesis appearing in the correct causal order?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Across registered regime-change events, constraint changes will precede persistent routing behavior, and persistent behavior will precede durable language and price-structure changes more often than the reverse ordering.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Rule",
   "gate": "Regime Legibility",
   "room": "ROOM-06-RECOGNITION",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 16, Mechanism → Behavior → Language → Price Structure"
  },
  {
   "id": "REG-PRICE-001",
   "question": "Is price beginning to reflect durable behavior?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Persistent upstream behavior will be followed by stronger relative price structure and retained weekly or monthly floors more often than by transient, fully reversed spikes.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Regime Legibility",
   "room": "ROOM-06-RECOGNITION",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 16, Relative Volatility and Compression"
  },
  {
   "id": "SET-BOUNDS-001",
   "question": "What range of real settlement is defensible?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Published lower, working, and upper economic-settlement bounds will preserve their qualitative conclusion under registered exclusion, transfer-band, currency-view, and source-sensitivity tests.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Settlement Quality",
   "room": "ROOM-05-SETTLEMENT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 14, bounded inference; Structure V1 §9.3"
  },
  {
   "id": "SET-CORR-001",
   "question": "Do independent observations support the inferred settlement range?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Filtered on-chain settlement estimates will move in the same direction as at least two independent economic anchors often enough to outperform raw-count and raw-volume baselines.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Settlement Quality",
   "room": "ROOM-05-SETTLEMENT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 14, triangulation with hard-to-fake anchors"
  },
  {
   "id": "SET-LEAD-001",
   "question": "Is behavior moving before the narrative?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "A sustained center-of-distribution increase that begins while price and search attention remain flat will predict later language or price updating more reliably than count-only spikes.",
   "state": "READY_UNSCORED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Settlement Quality",
   "room": "ROOM-05-SETTLEMENT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 14; Ch. 16, behavior-first regime"
  },
  {
   "id": "SET-MON-001",
   "question": "Is the center of activity rising and sustaining?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "A monetization signature requires transaction count and the distribution center to hold or rise together, with the higher center persisting across the registered post-stress window.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Settlement Quality",
   "room": "ROOM-05-SETTLEMENT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 14, ‘Monetization lifts the center and sustains it’"
  },
  {
   "id": "SET-NOISE-001",
   "question": "Is the count increase mostly noise?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Episodes in which transaction count rises while the median and nearby quantiles fall will fail external economic-activity corroboration or mean-revert more often than episodes in which the distribution center also rises.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Settlement Quality",
   "room": "ROOM-05-SETTLEMENT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 14, ‘Noise moves the count’"
  },
  {
   "id": "SET-TAIL-001",
   "question": "Is a small speculative tail moving the headline?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Episodes in which averages or upper-tail transfers rise while the median and nearby quantiles remain flat will not reliably predict broad, persistent economic settlement growth.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Intermediate",
   "gate": "Settlement Quality",
   "room": "ROOM-05-SETTLEMENT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 14, ‘Speculation moves the tail’"
  },
  {
   "id": "TSB-CORE-001",
   "question": "Is monetary demand beginning to reroute and consolidate around a second sovereign rail?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "If the macro migration state is reached and Bitcoin fee regimes repeatedly bind, a measurable share of economically relevant demand will reroute to sovereign alternatives; if Litecoin uniquely retains and coordinates that flow, its settlement footprint and holding duration will rise before broad language and relative price fully reclassify it.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Root",
   "gate": "Core Model",
   "room": "ROOM-01-CONTROL",
   "framework_anchor": "Act II Executive Summary; Constraint → Routing → Coordination"
  },
  {
   "id": "VAL-FLOW-001",
   "question": "What settlement and holding assumptions support this monetary base?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "For a registered settlement scenario, implied monetary base must rise proportionally with annual economic settlement and inversely with velocity; any dashboard scenario violating this relation is invalid.",
   "state": "ADOPTED_RULE",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Rule",
   "gate": "Valuation",
   "room": "ROOM-05-SETTLEMENT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 10 flow-to-stock hinge; Ch. 15, implied base ≈ annual settlement ÷ velocity"
  },
  {
   "id": "VAL-HOLD-001",
   "question": "Is Litecoin becoming held working money rather than pass-through inventory?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Litecoin monetary-base support will rise only if economically meaningful settlement grows or remains durable while average holding duration increases, lowering implied velocity.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Valuation",
   "room": "ROOM-05-SETTLEMENT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 14–15, settlement and velocity"
  },
  {
   "id": "VAL-PROB-001",
   "question": "Which probability branch did this evidence actually update?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "Repeated routing, unique retention, coordination gravity, and velocity compression will increase the registered conditional probability of Litecoin becoming the second rail; scattering, inadequacy, or permanent high velocity will reduce it.",
   "state": "METHOD_REQUIRED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Rule",
   "gate": "Valuation",
   "room": "ROOM-05-SETTLEMENT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 15 probability tree"
  },
  {
   "id": "VAL-RECLASS-001",
   "question": "Has monetary behavior changed, or only market price?",
   "falsifiable_claim": "A monetary reclassification state cannot be supported by price appreciation alone; it requires sustained economic settlement plus evidence of lower velocity or longer holding duration.",
   "state": "BLOCKED",
   "confidence": "NOT_ASSESSED",
   "level": "Gate",
   "gate": "Valuation",
   "room": "ROOM-05-SETTLEMENT",
   "framework_anchor": "Ch. 15, store of value as a velocity regime"
  }
 ],
 "edges": [
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-001",
   "from": "BTC-LIM-001",
   "to": "BTC-LIM-002",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-002",
   "from": "BTC-LIM-002",
   "to": "BTC-LIM-003",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-003",
   "from": "BTC-LIM-002",
   "to": "BTC-LIM-004",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-004",
   "from": "BTC-LIM-003",
   "to": "BTC-LIM-005",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-005",
   "from": "BTC-LIM-004",
   "to": "BTC-LIM-005",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-006",
   "from": "BTC-LIM-005",
   "to": "LTC-TRIAL-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-007",
   "from": "BTC-LIM-005",
   "to": "REG-LEG-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-008",
   "from": "BTC-LIM-005",
   "to": "TSB-CORE-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-009",
   "from": "BTC-LIM-005",
   "to": "VAL-PROB-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-010",
   "from": "LTC-BAND-001",
   "to": "LTC-RET-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-011",
   "from": "LTC-BAND-001",
   "to": "SET-MON-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-012",
   "from": "LTC-COORD-001",
   "to": "LTC-FLY-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-013",
   "from": "LTC-COORD-001",
   "to": "LTC-SECOND-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-014",
   "from": "LTC-CORR-001",
   "to": "LTC-COORD-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-015",
   "from": "LTC-CORR-001",
   "to": "LTC-SECOND-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-016",
   "from": "LTC-CORR-001",
   "to": "SET-CORR-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-017",
   "from": "LTC-CTRL-001",
   "to": "LTC-SECOND-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-018",
   "from": "LTC-FLY-001",
   "to": "LTC-SECOND-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-019",
   "from": "LTC-RET-001",
   "to": "LTC-COORD-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-020",
   "from": "LTC-RET-001",
   "to": "LTC-CORR-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-021",
   "from": "LTC-RET-001",
   "to": "LTC-CTRL-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-022",
   "from": "LTC-RET-001",
   "to": "SET-MON-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-023",
   "from": "LTC-SECOND-001",
   "to": "REG-LANG-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-024",
   "from": "LTC-SECOND-001",
   "to": "REG-LEG-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-025",
   "from": "LTC-SECOND-001",
   "to": "TSB-CORE-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-026",
   "from": "LTC-SECOND-001",
   "to": "VAL-HOLD-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-027",
   "from": "LTC-SECOND-001",
   "to": "VAL-PROB-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-028",
   "from": "LTC-TRIAL-001",
   "to": "LTC-BAND-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-029",
   "from": "LTC-TRIAL-001",
   "to": "LTC-RET-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-030",
   "from": "MAC-EXIT-001",
   "to": "MAC-EXIT-002",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-031",
   "from": "MAC-EXIT-001",
   "to": "MAC-EXIT-004",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-032",
   "from": "MAC-EXIT-002",
   "to": "MAC-EXIT-004",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-033",
   "from": "MAC-EXIT-003",
   "to": "MAC-EXIT-004",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-034",
   "from": "MAC-EXIT-004",
   "to": "MAC-COHORT-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-035",
   "from": "MAC-EXIT-004",
   "to": "MAC-MIG-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-036",
   "from": "MAC-MIG-001",
   "to": "REG-LEG-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-037",
   "from": "MAC-MIG-001",
   "to": "TSB-CORE-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-038",
   "from": "MAC-STAY-001",
   "to": "MAC-STAY-002",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-039",
   "from": "MAC-STAY-001",
   "to": "MAC-STAY-003",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-040",
   "from": "MAC-STAY-001",
   "to": "MAC-STAY-005",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-041",
   "from": "MAC-STAY-002",
   "to": "MAC-STAY-003",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-042",
   "from": "MAC-STAY-002",
   "to": "MAC-STAY-005",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-043",
   "from": "MAC-STAY-003",
   "to": "MAC-STAY-004",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-044",
   "from": "MAC-STAY-003",
   "to": "MAC-STAY-005",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-045",
   "from": "MAC-STAY-004",
   "to": "MAC-STAY-005",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-046",
   "from": "MAC-STAY-005",
   "to": "MAC-MIG-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-047",
   "from": "REG-LANG-001",
   "to": "REG-LEG-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-048",
   "from": "REG-LANG-001",
   "to": "REG-PRICE-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-049",
   "from": "REG-LEG-001",
   "to": "TSB-CORE-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-050",
   "from": "REG-PRICE-001",
   "to": "REG-LEG-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-051",
   "from": "SET-BOUNDS-001",
   "to": "REG-LEG-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-052",
   "from": "SET-BOUNDS-001",
   "to": "TSB-CORE-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-053",
   "from": "SET-BOUNDS-001",
   "to": "VAL-FLOW-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-054",
   "from": "SET-BOUNDS-001",
   "to": "VAL-HOLD-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-055",
   "from": "SET-BOUNDS-001",
   "to": "VAL-RECLASS-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-056",
   "from": "SET-CORR-001",
   "to": "SET-BOUNDS-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-057",
   "from": "SET-LEAD-001",
   "to": "REG-LANG-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-058",
   "from": "SET-LEAD-001",
   "to": "REG-PRICE-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-059",
   "from": "SET-MON-001",
   "to": "SET-BOUNDS-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-060",
   "from": "SET-MON-001",
   "to": "SET-CORR-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-061",
   "from": "SET-MON-001",
   "to": "SET-LEAD-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-062",
   "from": "SET-NOISE-001",
   "to": "SET-BOUNDS-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-063",
   "from": "SET-TAIL-001",
   "to": "SET-BOUNDS-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-064",
   "from": "VAL-HOLD-001",
   "to": "VAL-PROB-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-065",
   "from": "VAL-HOLD-001",
   "to": "VAL-RECLASS-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  },
  {
   "id": "CLAIM-EDGE-066",
   "from": "VAL-RECLASS-001",
   "to": "TSB-CORE-001",
   "relationship": "CANONICAL_CAUSAL_EDGE"
  }
 ]
}